Boeing Co. (NYSE:BA) is at a pivotal moment in its aerospace history as it faces significant challenges with its Starliner program. The recent decision by NASA to opt for SpaceX over Boeing’s Starliner to bring astronauts back from the International Space Station has placed the program’s future in jeopardy. Boeing’s newly appointed CEO, Kelly Ortberg, now finds himself at the helm, tasked with making crucial decisions that will determine the fate of the Boeing Starliner program.
The Starliner Program’s Struggles
The Boeing Starliner program, once a symbol of Boeing’s ambitions in space exploration, has faced numerous setbacks. NASA’s recent decision to exclude Starliner from its astronaut return missions is just one of many challenges the program has encountered. These difficulties come on the heels of a tumultuous year for Boeing, marked by a series of high-profile issues, including problems with the 737 Max and leadership changes at the top.
CEO Kelly Ortberg, who took the reins earlier this month, inherits the daunting task of navigating these challenges. The decision to continue investing in the Boeing Starliner program or potentially exit the initiative entirely is now a key dilemma facing the company’s leadership. According to aerospace analyst Robert Spingarn of Melius Research, “Do they ultimately exit the program because it’s too complicated, and because the other guy can do it better?” This question looms large as Ortberg and his executive team weigh the program’s future.
Financial Implications and NASA’s Role
Boeing’s financial woes further complicate the situation. The company has already incurred substantial losses on the Starliner program, including $1.6 billion in cost overruns. Analysts predict that the program could cost Boeing an additional $400 million if another test flight is required. With a projected cash burn of at least $5 billion this year, Boeing must carefully consider whether the Starliner program remains a viable investment.
NASA, on the other hand, faces its own set of challenges. The agency’s commercial crew program was designed to have multiple U.S. spacecraft available for missions to the ISS. While SpaceX has successfully launched nine crews since 2020, the Boeing Starliner program remains delayed by seven years. Despite these setbacks, Boeing continues to represent NASA’s best hope for maintaining a multi-partner strategy in space.
As Clayton Swope, deputy director of the Aerospace Security Project at the Center for Strategic and International Studies, points out, “If Boeing were to back out of its contract, that’s not a good outcome for NASA either. They’d have to start over with commercial crew.” NASA’s desire to keep Boeing in the program may lead to compromises, such as converting an autonomous Starliner flight into a cargo mission to ease Boeing’s financial burden.
The Path Forward
The future of the Boeing Starliner program hinges on its next test flight, scheduled for next month. This flight, which will return the spacecraft to Earth without astronauts on board, will be closely scrutinized by both Boeing and NASA. The results will likely influence Boeing’s decision to continue or abandon the program. NASA has not ruled out certifying Starliner for crewed missions, but additional test flights could be required, further straining Boeing’s finances.
Kelly Ortberg, as Boeing’s new CEO, has the authority to make sweeping changes, including potentially exiting the human spaceflight business. However, this decision is fraught with complexity, given Boeing’s long-standing legacy in space exploration, dating back to the Apollo moon landings. The Starliner program is just one of several fixed-price contracts that have weighed on Boeing’s defense and space division, which posted a $762 million operating loss in the first half of 2024.
Conclusion
As Boeing grapples with the challenges facing its Starliner program, the company must carefully balance its financial realities with its commitment to space exploration. The decisions made in the coming months will not only determine the future of the Boeing Starliner program but also impact NASA’s broader commercial crew strategy. For CEO Kelly Ortberg, the stakes are high, and the path forward remains uncertain. However, one thing is clear: the Boeing Starliner program is at a critical crossroads, with the potential to reshape the company’s role in the future of space travel.
Featured Image: Freepik